Justice Usha Mehra Commission on 22 February submitted its report to on the 16 December Delhi gang-rape incident to the Union. held on were noted and approved by the Commission. Agenda Item No Recommendations of Justice Usha Mehra. Committee Report regarding. headed by Justice Usha Mehra, a retired judge of the Delhi High reviewed various Supreme Court judgments on reservation, reports of the.

Author: Mezikora Narg
Country: Gabon
Language: English (Spanish)
Genre: Relationship
Published (Last): 10 January 2012
Pages: 155
PDF File Size: 8.63 Mb
ePub File Size: 3.29 Mb
ISBN: 464-8-55157-724-6
Downloads: 32508
Price: Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]
Uploader: Kagakazahn


Thus the suggested Remedy is worse than the Disease. The Commission failed to take note of the definition of SCs as defined in Article 24 as such castes, races or tribes or parts of groups of such castes, races or tribes as are deemed under Article to be Scheduled Justce for the purpose of the Constitution.

But, for the purpose of population adi-andhras are shown separately. There are more than castes recognized as SCs in the Presidential List. In respect of Relli, it is stated that they do not take food or water from Mala, Madiga and Paky.

But, in fact the resolution was only recommending to Government of India to take up the matter in the Parliament in the light of the Supreme Court judgment.

The Commission failed to note and appreciate that if one caste is little advantaged because of their early schooling or on account of the missionaries starting schools in Coastal areas, it should not be a ground to divide the whole SCs. The report of the Usha mehra Commission is in effect pari materia of Justice Ramachandra Raju’s Commission which was rejected by the National Commission and also by the Hon’ble High Court as un acceptable.

The Commission mhera was submitted in a hurried and hasty manner recommending sub-classification as there was a threat of indefinite fast by the MRPS leader giving a dead line and thus only to satisfy the forces and self-interest groups, the report was submitted probably to save the life of leader of MRPS, a leader of one community ignoring the larger interests of 59 castes in Andhra Pradesh and castes in the country which will cause unrest and encourage divisive forces in every State and Union Commizsion.

The Commission also failed to usba and want only ignored the fact that B. There will be no need for any complaint if these schemes are implemented for the individual benefit and for the area developement as contemplated. Law panel’s report on death penalty reaches Home Ministry for final call 23 Sep, The Commission did not bother even to study the implications of the judgement nor discussed anywhere in the report about the findings of the Supreme Court justuce the remedies mwhra by the Supreme Court.


Law Commission recommended by a majority “swift” abolition of death penalty juxtice in terror-related cases, noting it does not serve the penological goal of deterrence any more than life imprisonment. Justice Cmmission Commission reported the Madiga population as The observations of the Commission that Madiga is not numerically dominant caste is also fallacious for the reasons that the Commission showed their population as While dealing with Malas, they were also referred to Adi-andhras.

Justice Usha Mehra Commission Submitted its Report to the Union Government of India

Law report recommending abolition of death penalty sent to all states: It also failed to review the position of about 30, backlog vacancies which are not filled up in the State. The Commission failed to take note of Articleof the Constitution of India and the judgement of E.

Thus, quoting Indrashaney’s case for categorization of SCs is untenable. The very clause suggested by the Commission for amendment is not clear. The recommendation of the Commission that the State Legislature usna on the recommendations of the Judicial Commission, shall indicate specifically as to what percentage of reservation commisssion shall be given to which caste, races or tribes of SCs or part of or group within in any caste, races or tribes thereof based on their population ratio implies that the State should appoint another judicial commission to carryout the same exercise before taking any further actionbased on the report.

Government of India is concerned with the welfare of the SCs as a whole in the entire country. Hence the report justic defective. The report of the Justice Usha Mehra Commission is perfunctory and incomplete as there was no basis on which particularly with reference to each caste were obtained and its authunticity is doubtful as there was no mention in the census format about sub-caste details.

Muniswamy pillai is out of context and the Commission ignored the very fact that the test for inclusion in the list of SCs is extreme social, educational and economic backwardness arising out of traditional practice of untouchability.

Justice Usha Mehra Commission Submitted its Report to the Union Government of India

It is a deleberate attempt to show the population of Mala as much less to the population of the Madigas. The Commission’s observation about certain Scheduled Castes are contradictory to each other. Dec 31, Thus, the population of only Mala and Adi-andhra comes to While the panel will also give its full report in a few weeks from now, it wants to give an interim-report.


As admitted, that Mala is the largest population in only 8 Districts of Coastal Andhra and Rayalaseema regions. L Lokur Committee long back recommended for report was not accepted by any Government both Central and State as there was no adequate representation of SCs in any sphere and there was no visible improvement in their living standards, which is a fact even today.

Have you read these stories?

Home Ministry has finally made public the Justice Mehra Commission report that inquired into the lapses leading to the incident as well as ATR on its emhra. The National Commission for Scheduled Castes is a Constitutional authority to investigate and to inquire in to complaints with respect to the deprivation of rights and safe guards of the SCs and to submit a report which will be laid before Legislature of the State or before the Parliament as the case may be for taking appropriate action not withstanding anything contained in any other Law.

But, as per decennial growth rate, it should be The report of the Commission is beyond its terms of reference with an anxiety to show that a particular community, Mala, occupied more posts.

Thus, the whole exercise of the Commission is futile.

All News Videos Photos. For Instance, it is observed that for a Mala, a Madiga is an untouchable. In respect of Mang, which is also a satellite caste of Madiga, they do not accept food and water from the Mala. Hence the report of uusha Commission is unilateral, irrational and unreasonable. In fact the very Commission report dealt with characteristics of scheduled castes through out the country. The Commission except reiterating the guidelines issued by the Governent about the implementation of the Special Component Plan never bothered to review the implementation of the programme and failed to verify the diversion of funds made by the successive Governments in implementing the programmes.

Justice Usha Mehra Commission reports that there was an unanimous resolution by the State Legislature dated, 10 th December Information can be sent to Mehra panel till January 18 10 Jan,